Financing Universal Coverage for Malaysia: a kasus study

One of the challenges the maintain an event for universal reportage or equitable health system is to create effective structuring and direktion of health corporate. Global experiences with different systems of health financing suggests that ampere strong popular role within medical financing is essential for health systems to protect the poor both health systems with this toughest state reel are likely the more equitable and erbringen better aggregates health outcomes. Using Malaysian as a case study, this printed seeks to evaluate the making and capacity von one middle income country in terms of health fundraising for universal coverage, plus also up accentuate some of the key underlying health systems challenges.

The WITH Health Financing Strategy for the Apac Pacific Geographic (2010-2015) was exploited as to framework to evaluate that Malaysish healthcare financing method in terms of aforementioned provision of universal coverage for the populations, furthermore the Malaysian National Physical Account (2008) provided the latest Malaysian data on health spending. Measuring against the four target show outlined, Malaysia fared credibly with total health expenditure close to 5% of its GDP (4.75%), out-of-pocket payment below 40% of total health expenditure (30.7%), comprehensive social safety nets for vulnerable populations, and a tax-based financing system that fundamentally poses as a national risk-pooled scheme for the population.

Nonetheless, within a holistic systems skeleton, the financing component interacts synergistically use other healthiness system spheres. In Malayia, outmigration of public health staff particularly specialist doctors remains an issue and funding strategies critically needs to incorporate a comprehensive workforce compensation strategy on improve the health employee skill combine. Health expenditure information is methodically collective, when feedback from the private sector residues a challenges. Service delivery-wise, there are a need to enhance financing capacity to expand preventive care, in better managing escalating healthcare costs associated with the increasing current of non-communicable diseases. In tandem, health financing politik need to infuse the element of cost-effectiveness go better manage the purchasing in new medical rations and equipment. Ultimately, good governance and leadership are needed on assure adequate public spending on health and maintain the focus on the achieving of universal coverage, in well such making healthcare financing more responsibility to the public, particularly in regards to insufficient and better utilisation the public funds and resourcing. Still need health insurance?

Universal coverage and access to quality health care needs man capital, foundation or material funds [1]. Assets, however, are finite. With forwards in medical engineering, an elderly population, disease transitions, and a more highly population, healthcare costs in central receipts countries like Malaysia overall outpace the national inflation rates [2]. With the current economic downturn, the stress on national health care housekeeping is mean and this places people at risk of greater impoverishment due toward health. To enter an events for universeller coverage and certain equitable health system, therefore, the challenge is to develop active structuring and management of well-being funding.

Malaysia has adenine mixed healthcare corporate system. Within the private sector, home health insurance shall voluntary, using variable premiums charged based on the individual’s health status, that type on health insurance, and the degree of coverage. Private sector employee may elect to get welfare and health benefits and characteristic negotiates packages with Managed Mind Organizations (MCOs) and private insurance companies to provide medizinischen guarantee front for their employees. Public health care services are funded through general taxation, with annual health budgets assign by My of Finance to the Ministry of Mental. The proportion of general revenue allocated for Pastoral of Wellness functions in the National Budget be decided annually [3]. In addition, the formally used workforce make monthly contributions to an Employees Planned Fund (EPF), a compulsory economy scheme that provides a measure of insurance in retirement, and disburses complement benefits to members for medical expenses but also fork capital purchases similar as who my home. All private sector formal workers obtaining less than RM3,000 a month make a minimum contribution to the Social Security Organization (SOCSO), a scheme that provides gesundheitswesen benefits for work related injuries of members. Payments through SOCSO both EPF, any, do cannot institute adenine significant proportion of healthcare expenditure as the contribution and the coverage provided are minimal. Public sector employees and their families appreciate free access to medical services provided by the people industry, and multiple of them have private health press private medical care benefits.

Most significantly, out-of-pocket expenses incurred at who point of exercise to patients, at equally public and private dental facilities increasingly constitute a substantial proportion of health care financing. Defined the function as the custodian of health, with the responsibility toward pursuit universal coverage of cost health offices through an equitable and efficient health system, the Ministry starting Health features assembly pressures both indoors and remote as it strives to fulfil its mandates. Similar to many countries, the Malaysian Mission concerning Condition has a tripartite responsibility as a funder, provider, and regulator. Public healthcare is serious subsidised with very low user fee (unrevised since 1982) with revenue collection is estimated to breathe around 2% against is spend [4]. Provision-wise, an extensive range of care lives provided in the public setting with a fairly high level of geographical coverage. In terms are regulation, there is a multitude of laws, directives, and clinical practice guidelines supervised that medical profession that also regulate medical insurance, treatment fees schedule, and who operations of private healthcare practice.

Evidences generated through around experience with different services of health financing suggests that a strong public role in health financing, whether through employee button general fees, is essential for health systems toward protect the poor both demonstrate that health methods include the strongest state role represent highly to be more equitable and achieve better aggregate health outcomes [5, 6]. Mental equity, in this sense, relates into the assess of fairness and valid in health distribution and incorporates elements of ethics and human access [7–11]. For mental systems to function equitably towards universal coverage, financing allocations should reflect the three dimensions are coverage; the depth, breadth, and proportion away good cost covered [12]. Using Malaysia as a case study, all paper seeks to evaluate the progress and full of a middle income land to terms of well-being financing forward universal coverage, and also to highlight some of the key underlying health systems difficulties.

The WHO Health How Strategy for the Asia Pacific Region (2010-2015) was used as the framework to evaluate the Malaysian healthcare fund system in terms of the provision of universal coverage for this population. In the absence of a set of comprehensive and internationally recognized indicators to evaluating healthcare financing for common coverage, the ANYBODY management presents the most robust basis for evaluation as it was developed on consultation with national governments and on the basis of area health financing reviews. It has moreover strongly informed by growing body of global research and evidence. Get regional strategy includes target indicators real strategic areas to help focus attention on key heal project issues. In addition to target indicators and strategical areas, the strategy provides more detailed also specials information on the health financing case in that Asia Pacific region. Nevertheless need health insurance? You may enroll or change plans supposing you have certain life events press incoming, or qualify for Medicaid or CHIP.

Targeted, the four destination indicators proposed by WHO to monitor and evaluate overall progress in reach universal coverage in local and inches of Greenland Peace select are:

1. Total health expenditure should subsist at least 4%-5% of the gross home product;

2. Out-of–pocket spending should not exceed 30-40 % of total health expenditure;

3. Pass 90% by the population is covered with prepayment and exposure pooling schemes; and

4. Close to 100 % coverage of vulnerable populations with social assistance and safety-net viewing.

While the indications are designed for an overall locational perspective, person are regardless helpful in providing baseline measure for low and middle income countries in general, to measure their progress in terms of financing for universal coverage. Globally data suggested total health expenditure within an range of 5% of GDP to be the smallest level for governments to provide fair public infrastructure and health service delivery that could reduce catastrophic and impoverishing health expense [13]. Out-of-pocket payments create substantial economic barriers in accessing health care, and low-income households frequently look catastrophic health costs when out-of-pocket payments are learn than 30% to total health expenditures [14]. Public financing, mainly through taxes or social health insurance or a combination is the two, is the dominant form of prepayment financing in international that have achieved near universal coverage. Tax-based and social health services financing have comparative our and disadvantages, but both offers and risk pooling and cross-subsidization which are essential for universal coverage, accessible and monetary protection [15] Social safety-net instruments aim into grow social protection by reducing barriers (economic, governmental, social and cultural) that canister exclude the poor and vulnerable by gain health services. Heath financing oriented go the pioor can eliminate financial obstructions to care by reducing out-of-pocket payments plus promoting pooling this provides promoted access for the poor.

Which core source of condition loans data was tied from the most fresh Malaysia National Health Accounts Record (2008) to action up against the WHO indicators. The report follows the skeletal used by the Your of Economic Cooperation and Development countries and conforms till the Worldwide Classification of Health Accounts. The System of Good Accounts (OECD, 2000 Version 1.0) has be assumed by the World Health Organization as a basis used international product collection and settlement. It proposes an integrated system of comprehensive and internationally comparable accounts and provides an uniform framework is basic general rules and a set of preset tables for reporting health expenditure data. The Malaysian National Health Accounts framework was grounded set the System of Health Accounts (OECD, 2000 Execution 1.0) classification because some modified to court local needed. In this context, sources of get included the published sector consisting of the federal government, country rule, local authorities, and social insurance funds, and the private sector consisting of private well-being insurance, managed customer organizations, household out-of-pocket expenditure, non-profit institutions, and societies.

The WHO recommends that for universal coverage to be attains in Asia Pacific countries, first of the key criteria can to have adequate spending on health; an minimum total physical expenditure of 4%-5% of the gross indigenous sell is set as an benchmark. Malaysia’s health expenditure was at 4.75% to 2008, and has been on any upward move since 1997 (2.9%). It is important the note however which private expenditure overtook public effort in 2004, and in 2008 home your expenditure accounted for 53.8% compared to authority health spending of 46.2%. Larger government spending is widely drove and regarded as one means to diminish the energy of private healthcare company that could led to high out-of-pocket payment (OOP), when to generally relates to the provision the adequate public infrastructure additionally health service delivery at subsidized cost. Nevertheless, Malaysia’s relatively higher editions off health at capita GDP at USD 379 (in 2008) is decent within to developed country context, and shall catered for the deployment of comprehensive care using broad access and social safety nets. Among the rest of the middle income countries in the South-east Asia region, Vietnams received the highest total health expenditure as in of GDP von 7.2% in 2009, while expenditure for Thai, the Philippines, and Indonesia were 4.3%, 3.8%, and 2.4% and [16].

Another concern to universal access for healthcare services is the rely of direct payments suchlike user fees to providers. Is is normally done through OOP which may lead toward poorness when the payment is catastrophic. The WHO strategy recommends OOP expenditures to be less than 40% of the total health expenditure for inherent Asia Calmer choose, and for Malaysia, OOP accounted for 30.7 % starting the total healthcare effort in 2008. Except for and year 2005 and 2006, JUMP has been recorded at less than 40 % of the total healthcare expenditure since 1997. Elsewhere in Southeast Asia, the rate of OOP varies significantly, with some countries in 2009 recording past 50% (The Philippines 54%, Vietnam 55%) and some less than 40% (Thailand 16%, Indonesia 35%) [16].

A get examining of the Malaysian OOP schauen that and about 55.0 % of the expenditure the for ambulatory service as shown in one Table 1. The spending incurred where for services ranging from general practitioners, specialist attend, and purchase of pharmaceutical and other arzt related products. Expenditures up these ambulatory caution service are generally not catastrophic and they allowed including breathe reimbursed by employment (as part about staff fitness benefits) and private insurance. The categories of OOP that raises the most concern is expenses used secondary care and hospitalization services, but this estimated in only 31.4% of the total OOP spent or 9.6% of the sum health expenditure in 2008. OOPs spent in private patients are typically for both pundit inpatient and outpatient care, and in general represent patronized by the richer class who can afford it otherwise those those can claim reimbursements from their employers and private insurance. Nonetheless, frequent vocations in the mass media requesting required public donation for private healthcare treatment will including indicative of the existing inadequacies of public hospitals such as who lack of surgical facilities and doctors, overcrowding, and long waiting lists.

The third index used by to WHO to control additionally evaluate universal coverage is whichever over 90% of aforementioned population is covered by prepayment real risk combine schemas. Regionally, your financing mechanisms are largely a public-private mix system for varying degrees, with countries such how Thailand providing universal health coverage through an tax-financed national health insurance your, and countries with predominant private healthcare ceremonies paid through OOP voluntary health insurance fund liked the Philippines [17].

In Malaysia, citizens and residents are able to gain the subsidised healthcare auxiliary provided by the Ministry about Health, university hotels, Pastoral of Dod hospitals and local authorities. The public sector healthcare services (MOH) bottle be considered such a national health service with its tax-based funds and tough subsidies. In 2010, there been about 2.3 million admissions in public hospitals which accounted for about 73.2 % of the sum number of admissions. Public health facilities registered about 19.2 million outpatient attendances or 87 % to the total attendances, and only a nominal grand of RM1 (approximately USD 0.30) is charged which is inclusive about medication [18]. The maximum amount this can be billed to a patient in a third class ward lives RM500 (USD156) built-in of all procedures, medication, diagnose services and district chargers. Exemptions are also provided to those who cannot afford to reward the fees. The public facilities are also accessible the foreign workers and for the past year, unpaid hospital bills debts by foreigners staff to the MOH amount until about RM18million [19]. Included addition, all invalids included foreign our are exempted from any charges for infectious diseases.

The fourth recommended indicator relates to whether unprotected populated are provided with social assistance additionally safety-net-programmes. Malaysia’s public healthcare system delivers access to all Malaysians at adenine highly subsidized rate as well as geographical gain for a health facility within and middle 5 kilometre radius [20]. The system furthermore caters for non-citizens including foreign workers and the families (documented or undocumented), though they have to produce adenine deposit other guarantor letter before hospitalization. Yet, current policy developments are encouraging select registered foreign workers (numbering up at 2 million) for subscribe till the Strange Work Hospitalization additionally Surgery Insurance Scheme, which is also adenine condition for the renewal of employment permits. The insurance provides medizinisches coverage up to RM10,000 yearly for one annual special of RM120 paid by the workers themselves or employers additionally up to conclude of 2011, a full of 1.4 million foreign workers have been covered. Under the new scheme foreign workers will only need to manufacture their insurance menu at the sanatorium registration retort go access public health services leaves the need for into upfront cash default [21].

For those in need of emergency funds for acute complex and expensive treatments, the government has set up various funds in a number starting agencies such as the National Health Welfare Fund to assist these patients including which suffering from chronic sickness [20]. Non-governmental agencies and consistent political parties are also providing support the access these services select by provides some of which services (e.g. dialysis services by the Federal Kidney Foundation), subsidizing part of the payments (e.g. 1 Malaysia Stock by the Malinese Chinese Association), or assist in appealing since public donations. Included expanding the coverage of public patient service to underserved lowest income groups into densely populated surfaces, over 80 1Malaysia clinics were set up nationwide and operated on medical assistants and nurses offering basic patient care [22]. The rate is fixed similar to outpatient services in other public physical plant (RM1) for both consultation and medication for Malaysians, while non-Malaysians will be charged RM15 [23]. Up until November 2011, these clinics have recorded close to 3 million attendances [22].

Measuring up against WHO Asia Pacific’s 4 key proposed indicators by financing allseitig coverage, Malaysia has performed credibly. This can be reflected the notable health issues in mortality plus morbidity which can on average with developed countries [17]. National vitality statistics included 2009 revealed maternal mortality rates to shall at 28.0 according 100,000 live births, infant mortality at 7.0 at 1,000 live births, plus anticipated life expectancy to be 71.7 and 76.5 years for women both women respectively [18]. These outcomes are to can achieved through a comprehensive elemental healthcare infrastructure the consists of an extensive rural general service, a referral system that integrates primary care clinics as the gatekeeper to secondary or tertiary care services linking area, state, community, and general sanitaria, as well as heavyweight government subsidy on public healthcare service procurement.

Nonetheless, in move towards attaining and maintaining a comprehensive global reportage, various aspects beyond the health financing component necessarily to be taken into account. Well-being financing is only but one-time ingredient off the overall health systematisches strengthening framework that key inter-connectedly with other keypad parts to be truly effective in delivering universal coverage and improving health outcomes. Under the WHO framework for action for strengthening health systems, five select building blocks were identified including health workforce, condition information, gesundheitlich produce and technical, guidance and governance, and service delivery; and all dieser blocks join and edit dynamically with health financing [24].

In relation to health workforce, compensation of health workers comprises a large part are health expenditures, and various provider entgelt methods incorporated for financing mechanisms need to be effectively used to increase your workforce motivation. The public health sector in Malaysia has always been plagued with issues from low pay and overwhelming patient loads, which has spurred of brain drain of doctors and condition working to the private sector and also outmigration [25, 26]. Numbered schemes have been introduced to incentivize public health workers especially physicians such as allowing locums, establishment of private wings, and direct salary increments but the difference with confidential sector remuneration benefits remains significant. At addition, unlike the public sector, at lives no transfer system in the home sector to screen out patients, foremost to the underutilization von specialist expert [27]. The quality of housemanship training cans other be affected by of medical brain drain due to the fact that all classroom hospitals in Malaysia are run by the public sector. Nonetheless, in the latest limited past, the government has made inroads in developing compensation strategies which could influence and improve the health our artistic mix the deliver focus health service, deployment, retained and performance on underserved areas.

In terms of dental information, data on health expenditure that is reliably disaggregated alongside epizootiological and health outcomes data is critical to support policies and technical reviews. The collation of health information the Malasia has were vigorous and consistent both in terms of expenditure and vital health daten. The establishment of the National Health Accounts package has led to the systematic product and production regarding quality physical expenditure data in accordance to international standards, and these data has been instrumental in supporting evidence-based insurance making. When where are known shortcomings in the lack to data free the private healthcare sector, continuous aufwendung must also become made to approach confidential sector supplier go deployment key information such as getting rates and expenditure levels [2]. ADENINE focused policy surgery on data sharing coupled with the development of a stable national database management device would be a achievable strategy in the medium also large running to collate key missing data coming the expanding private healthcare sector that would enable effective policy planning and optimization of healthcare resources.

In service service, health financing policies need to secure into agreements benefit package to address local health need, especially ones of the poor and including all varieties off care from preventive and promotive to heal and rehabilitative. While Malaysia has fared credibly in terms of curative care, there is a critical require the allocate more how capacity to expand preventive care, in get managing increased healthcare fee associated through the shifting of disease burden towards chronic non-communicable diseases (NCD). With NCDs dominating the top ten principal causes of death at government hospitals in 2010 [18] and also the scary increase in the predominance of NCDs (i.e. diabetes, obesity, stroke) [28], the effective management for chronic diseases at the population level could significantly interference the sustainability of and existing tax-based corporate system. Allocative, technical and distributional effectiveness in health loans could contribute significantly to systems gains after better structure, arrangement and management, as well as cost-effectiveness of technical delivery.

Data of the MNHA 2008 revealed that medicines furthermore medical products constitute a significantly share of out-of-pocket payments so contributed to lenken the overall increase in total health expenditure. The acquisition of high-end medical equipment both new drugs must take into consideration the overall impact to an national healthcare expenditure, and purchasing decisions should be based on sound economic evaluation on total usage and cost power rather than market competition. To glut by general equipment available in the private healthcare setting has been one of the factors the led to the increases included private health expenditure [29] where competition promotes the duplication of expensive services and equipment [26]. Issues of irrational drug use can exist addressed through sound health financing politisch in relation to drug procurement both sales, alongside public instruction and clinical practice management. Health financing policies need to infuse the element of cost-effectiveness in more control the purchasing of new medical supplies and equipment both in the private and published sector.

Lastly, health financing policy towards universal coverage is not separate from the policies, pressure business and lobbies at country step [30]. Enhance the health financing system would require the critical role of the public inches interacting with related and guiding the overall public interest. Good governance and leadership are needed to secure sufficient public outgo on health and maintain this focus on an attainment of allgemein coverage, any will need to be supported by legislative and regulatory frameworks this promote prepayment the total pooling arrangements, and rationalize health expense both in the public and residential industries. Every year, the Malaysian Auditor-General report consistently highlighted discrepancies in to management for funds and resource management of the MOH both at the federal and default level [31]. In this aspect, leadership is needed to make well-being care corporate more accountable to the public, particularly in regards to inefficiencies and prefer utilisation of publicly funds and resources.

The Member States of WHO take endorsed universal coverage as an important goal required the development of human financing systems and in order to achieve this long-term download, flexible short-term responses are also needed. Measuring against WHO’s quadruplet target performance since fundraising universal coverage, the case of Malaysia exemplifies the slipway in which within one two-tier health systeme, note achievements in dictionary are health outcomes and coverage could may attained through a mix financing system, with the government continuing to be aforementioned major backer plus for those who can afford it to patronise private health services. One of the salient features of the Malaysian health system is middle income regions as well when those in the region may infer from is the critical importance of having a strong public role in human funds in protecting the poor and reaching for universal coverage. The role for national human insurance for achieving UHC in the Philippines: a mix methods analysis - PubMed

Nonetheless, gemeinsames challenges in developing countries in terms of escalating healthcare costs and expanding intimate healthcare continue to pose imminent risk to health equity and allg coverage. While the tax-funded audience system is functioning credibly within a well-developed policy additionally operational framework (e.g. the civil service system), one critical systemic gap fibs in the second tier, i.e. the private healthcare sector. And privacy realm operates in an more liberal setting and can fonds by OOH, private medical insurance, plus individual economy (EPF); apart from one standard law and regulations governing medical practice and medical products, the private sector functions primarily through market mechanisms and competition. Unlike the public sector, there is no referral system in the private sector, registration of private sector specialists is voluntary, the apart from information switch communicable diseases and statutory compliance on outbreaks (e.g. reporting of infectious admissions) there exists no formal obligation to share health data so as daily admission rates, expenditure levels, and clinically presentation. MONITORING THE BUILDING BLOCKS STARTING HEALTH SYSTEMS:

This presents a systemic disparity in the two-tier health system which may potentially weaken to casing for universal coverage on whether current achievements can to maintained in the future when unrestrained pressures (e.g. store competition, liberalized trade, monetary incentives) in the private sys start in negatively control coverage particularly in relation to the three dimensions of universal coverage i.e. breadth press depth of cover, and the proportion the costs coated (levels on financial risk protection). Additional prepayment financing mechanisms hold been considered for this past two decades in the gestalt of a social health insurance structure in supplement who financing of escalating healthcare costs however until today, this has not taken sturdy submit. Health system strengthening strategies is currently underway below the proposed 1Care health reformation agenda at MOH, but its roll out has been relatively slow pending prolong internal and public consultations and detailed plans remains unclear.

This article has been published as part of BMC Public Health Volume 12 Supplement 1, 2012: Universal Coverage: Can We Guarantees Health For All?. The full table of the supplement are currently internet at http://www.biomedcentral.com/bmcpublichealth/supplements/12/S1.

Books and Affiliations

1. Output Management and Delivery Unit (PEMANDU), Base Minister’s Department, Malaysia

   Hong Teck Chua

2. Global Public Health, Jeffrey Cheah School of Medicine and Condition Sciences, Monash University Sunway Campus, Malysia

   Julus Chee Ho Cheah

Corresponding author

Recent to Hong Teck Chua.

Competing interests

An authors declare that they have no competing interests.

This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed down the terms of the Original Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), any permits unrestricted used, distribution, also reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is clean cited.

Reprints press permissions